Coolmine - south bound ticket machines and why to never board without a ticket

[Mark Hennessy]

Originally Posted by andyl222

had my day in court today, and i'm delighted to say my case got thrown out i'm very relieved because the fines were getting bigger n bigger as the day progressed. 500 euro n 100 euro costs, thats pricey. Alot of fare evasion cases today,a few of which were just given the probation act, no fine or anything.

Nice one, the muppetry from Irish Rail in your case was unbelievable.

[ThomasJ]

Can I be so bold as to ask andyl222 what was the reason for it being thrown out?

[andyl222]

Originally Posted by ThomasJ

Can I be so bold as to ask andyl222 what was the reason for it being thrown out?

the solicitor had NO eveidence against me,so they couldnt proceed. judge just threw it out.

[Mark Gleeson]

So escape by technicality not on the merits of the case.

Any other day and you would have likely been hit with the €500 fine

[andyl222]

Originally Posted by Mark Gleeson

So escape by technicality not on the merits of the case.

Any other day and you would have likely been hit with the €500 fine

Possibly, but i'm too happy to care. This has been hanging over me for a year and a half so now that its over i'm just happy to relax.

[ThomasJ]

Originally Posted by Mark Gleeson

So escape by technicality not on the merits of the case.

Any other day and you would have likely been hit with the €500 fine

But short of checking the security cameras on the platforms for evidence how can this be proven?

[Mark Gleeson]

The official who issued the notice typically gives evidence of the incident involved.

Its the same as the classic I got off since the garda who caught me didn't show up in court.

Be very clear here, if you board at a staffed station without a ticket the full force of the law will be applied. I know of a few people in the court today. End of the day if you boarded without a ticket at a staffed station there is a case, the law has been broken.

You might get lucky, through a combination of Irish Rail messing up or the judge being friendly. Or you might get up to €1000 fine, a criminal conviction and a loss of income from a half day off

[andyl222]

Originally Posted by Mark Gleeson

The official who issued the notice typically gives evidence of the incident involved.

Its the same as the classic I got off since the garda who caught me didn't show up in court.

Be very clear here, if you board at a staffed station without a ticket the full force of the law will be applied. I know of a few people in the court today. End of the day if you boarded without a ticket at a staffed station there is a case, the law has been broken.

You might get lucky, through a combination of Irish Rail messing up or the judge being friendly. Or you might get up to €1000 fine, a criminal conviction and a loss of income from a half day off

And I have not disputed that fact at all, I was simply trying to point out that the glorious irish rail is not infallable in the eyes of the law. I'm in no way trying to condone fare evasion or anything like that, I was simply trying to pint out that sometimes irishrail get it wrong and a judge will rectify that.

[Coolmine99]

Good result andy, just make sure you have aticket the next time. (I know I will, even if it means being late for work)

Still no sign of my penalty fare, so they're obviously as sloppy in issuing these are they are with running services in general... I have rang and written to IR about it, so the ball is in their court (no pun intended).

[andyl222]

Originally Posted by Mark Gleeson

So escape by technicality not on the merits of the case.

Any other day and you would have likely been hit with the €500 fine

And also I did note that there were several cases similar to mine where a person got on a train due to an unforeseen circumstance and when they explained themselves the judge agreed that it didnt sound like fair evasion and they were given the probation act and no fine what so ever. So it would seem that people can win against irish rail,and not just through technicalities.